You keep using that word…
I wrote an article on soft power a few years ago, trying to clarify what it is and is not. I think it was a good article, and has generated a good amount of engagement. What I didn’t realize when I wrote it, however, was that it would turn me into the IR version of the boy from The Sixth Sense. Everywhere I look, I see bad uses of the term “soft power.” It’s actually turning into a mini-series here on the Duck. The latest provocation comes from the Chronicle of Higher Education.
The object of my ire
A recent issue of the Chronicle’s “Latitudes” newsletter caught my attention. This newsletter is a round-up of various news and events on higher education. One of the stories featured in the email I received mentioned the United States and UK leading on a ranking of soft power.
The story referenced a new report by the Higher Education Policy Institute, a British think tank. The institution releases a “soft power ranking,” with the US and UK currently on top. The report is admirably transparent with its methodology, noting it studies where “very very important people” are educated. The group also releases the raw data that goes into the report, which is also great.
A common issue is that people present the prerequisites of soft power as the exercise of soft power
The study itself is impressive, and very useful. This likely took a lot of work. Tracking where world leaders are educated is helpful in understanding what knowledge is available to policymakers and what networks exist in world politics. But none of this is soft power.
What soft power is
As most readers of this site will know, the term soft power was coined by Joseph Nye, as “the ability to get others to want what you want.” It is an attractive power, enabling a state to advance its interests without resorting to military threats, economic inducement or, arguably, diplomatic pressure. Nye argued this can come from a variety of sources, such as a vibrant popular culture, foreign aid, public diplomacy and, yes, education.
One issue with common usages of this term is, as I discussed in my article, its stretching. People often point to any attempt by a state to influence others that is not economic or military as soft power. This is not accurate. Soft power is a specific type of power politics that relies on the diffuse exercise of power to integrate international efforts. States could use symbolic or cultural appeals to directly influence one state, or use them for disruptive purposes. But these are not soft power. Some have tried to coin neologisms for these disruptive practices—sharp power—but that’s not necessary if we just keep a clear definition of soft power.
Another issue is that people present the prerequisites of soft power as the exercise of soft power. Alternately, they seem to think of soft power as a resource that states bank through these factors. But power is ultimately relational; resources can make power possible, but power comes from interaction with other actors. So studies will discuss foreign aid as soft power. Even public opinion of a country is not soft power, as that does not necessarily translate into real influence.
Those who think soft power matters need to take data like this, and test whether it does translate into real influence for states
I addressed this with some of my work on states’ use of religion in their foreign policy. Gregorio Bettiza and I wrote a chapter on US religious outreach in the Cold War in an edited volume. We noted that this alone did not create soft power for the United States, and it at times had a disruptive effect. Erdi Ozturk and I also explored this in an article on Turkish foreign policy, noting that the interaction between Turkey and Balkans states generated soft power, not Turkey’s possession of religious resources. I took a more systematic approach to this in my latest book, Religious Appeals in Power Politics. I argued that the effective use of religious appeals is relatively rare, with most deployments leading to international tensions and confusion. This was the case even for states that seem to possess significant religious resources, like Saudi Arabia.
This had to do with religion, but the takeaway applies to other manifestations of soft power. Merely possessing resources relevant to soft power is not enough to ensure a state is able to influence others without coercion.
I’m not (just) being cranky
This matters, for both real-world and academic reasons. Despite its popularity as a buzz-word, instruments of soft power rarely dominate discussions on foreign policy. Making tendentious arguments about soft power doesn’t help. Likewise, it’s hard to get academics to take discussions of soft power seriously, partly because it’s so hard to demonstrate it matters.
I’m trying not to trash this study, which I—again—think is great for what it is. It’s useful to know who is educated where. And it may be relevant to soft power. The key word, however, is may. Those who think soft power matters need to take data like this, and test whether it does translate into real influence for states.


0 Comments